Trained incapacity at the highest levels of the academy

“There are some ideas so absurd that only an intellectual could believe them.”

George Orwell

Paul Krugman as ever had the right expression. An intellectual crackup. Just in the 1930s when it was becoming obvious that communism, if it was to liberate humanity was certainly going to do it via an extraordinary degree of brutality, so there were plenty of intellectuals doubling down on how great it was. Likewise as the US Republican party has disappeared into conspiracy, paranoia and creationism as it’s given itself over to cranks and wackos, there’s been lots of support for its basic ideas not just from academic hucksters like George Gilder but also from those at the highest levels of the academy.

New classical economics is the perfect preparation for this because it’s tricky to excel in its maths and while you’re doing it you might miss the fact that its micro-foundations are absurd. The new classical explanation for the Great Depression is that it was a spontaneous holiday taken by rational, forward looking utility maximising workers.

Anyway there’s a cast of oddballs with Nobel Prizes in economics who buy this stuff and last week John Cochrane who’s a leading, but not Nobel Prize winning light at Chicago let us know how we could cure all known diseases massively expand the US economy by slashing regulation.

Anyway, Brad Delong made easy work of this and Cochrane offered a woeful response. Greg Mankiw likes to stay out of trouble, but couldn’t help himself from linking to Cochrane. And Noah Smith Taylor delivers the coup de grace.

I particularly recommend Brad’s slides which you should be able to follow just by imagining what jargon like “out of sample” must mean.

This entry was posted in Economics and public policy. Bookmark the permalink.
Notify of

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
I am and will always be Not Trampis
I am and will always be Not Trampis
7 years ago

Great minds think a like but it is Noah Smith!

I am and will always be Not Trampis
I am and will always be Not Trampis
7 years ago

Nick I linked you together with Brad and Noah in my much more simple article!

I am and will always be Not Trampis
I am and will always be Not Trampis
7 years ago

Why would Cochrane says such obvious nonsense, After all he isn’t a Kates.

He is the real deal. He must have known how weak his argument was yet he published the rubbish in the WSJ. Why?