Weekend Quiz

Posted in Uncategorised

Who said this?

Though it sounds paradoxical to say that . . . to prevent ourselves from making the wrong decision we must deliberately reduce the range of choice before us, we all know that this is often necessary in practice if we are to achieve our long term aims.

13 Comments

  1. The Worst of Perth

    Sounds too forward thinking for Hitler. How about Peter Costello?

  2. Nicholas Gruen

    Nope

  3. Ken Parish

    I cheated and used Google, so I'll disqualify myself.

  4. Sinclair Davidson

    Is he saying 'we' the individuals or 'we' the comunity?

  5. The Worst of Perth

    OK, a serious guess. Kissinger?

  6. Nicholas Gruen

    Sinclair,

    'We' is intended in the singular on my reading.

  7. Nicholas Gruen

    And it's not Kissenger. Ken, I hadn't even thought of Google as it's deep in a book that's not on the net. But you're right - the quote turns up in secondary literature.

  8. Sinclair Davidson

    I would have thought so. How individuals restrict their choices is very interesting and would form a better basis for behavioural economics than the sort of irrtionality type arguments we currently see. Unfortunately I haven't yet read the mystery persons book in this area.

  9. Geoff Honnor

    I suspect, looking at the Server's choice of links, the obvious "not who'd you'd expect" tone of your post and the veneration that is accorded to them in the immediate blogospherical vicinity - Popper or Hayek or Friedman.

  10. Nicholas Gruen

    Sinclair,

    I suspect you have read the book - for reasons alluded to by Geoff.

  11. Sinclair Davidson

    I have read the book that has the quote (pg 59), also the 1958 article in Ethics. I haven't read his work on theoretical psychology.

  12. Nicholas Gruen

    p. 66 in the copy I've got!

  13. Sinclair Davidson

    You have the University of Chicago Press edition and I have the Routledge edition (at home and the other at work). I read somewhere that all editions of Keynes' General Theory have the same pagination, a very sensible notion for classic works such as your mystery person.

    Geoff - you should have a serious guess.