National Service and Conscription

Pressing on with the Les Darcy research and the things that you find out whether you wanted to know or not. I should have mentioned that the Park/Champion book is available in paperback from quality booksellers etc.
The foundation for the book was was laid by Darcy Niland (named after the boxer) who conducted many interviews during the 1950s while numerous people who knew Les were still alive and sound in mind.
Darcy Niland died before he started to organise his research notes and these were kept by Ruth Park until she was about to donate them to the Mitchell Library when she decided that we could keep the work in the family (Ruth is the mother of the Rathouse webmistress).
Continue reading

Cutting the top marginal rate

More slime less philosophy.gif

As Mark Bahnisch said to me having read a draft of this week’s Courier Mail column, “Getting pissed off is often good for one’s writing”. Well, I’m not sure, but it certainly works for this genre. I’m thoroughly pissed off with the latest turn of events and so am grateful that I get the chance to put my case in the paper.

Most of the efficiency arguments for cutting top marginal tax rates are not too hot, and downright poor when one considers that almost all taxes distort – so if you want to argue against some tax, you have to show how its unusually bad. Anyway I’ve argued these things in various columns before. For instance here and here.

As I argue in the column this issue is a critical one for the ALP because so many of those policies for which the labour movement had high hopes either make life worse for most working people (eg. tariffs) or are ambiguous in their effects helping ‘insiders’ and hurting ‘outsiders’ (as I argue below is the case with most IR regulation including the basic wage).

As I suggest at the end of the piece, it’s also (yet another) loss of contact with the recent sucesses of the ALP, which was – uniquely amongst English speaking countries in the 1980s and 90s, economic liberalisation with a strongly redistributive flavour. The bargain between Paul Keating and Brian Howe.

Helen Clarke was able to sell this message in NZ, and indeed argued for higher taxes at the top end and got into government with that message. Whether one wants to embrace that (and top rates were much lower when she argued that) going the other way seems to me to be politically silly. A kind of rerun of the budget debacle when the ALP found a way of letting the Government off the hook for cutting taxes (for the second time) exclusively for those on higher incomes.

Anyway, the column is over the fold.
Continue reading

Something a bit different

One of my most interesting writing projects was to work with Ruth Park on a historical biography of the boxer and sporting icon Les Darcy. This involved some fascinating research into the events that led up to the row over conscription. It also involved a lot of research on Darcy’s fights which did not end up in the book due to lack of space and complaints from a senior officer in Penguin that the early manuscript had too much fighting in it. Doh!

Anyway, for the benefit of the cultured and discriminating Troppo readers who appreciate the finer things in life, including the sweet science of pugilism, here are some of the fruits of research on the fights of Les Darcy. The aim was to draw as much as possible on contemporary accounts.

THE FEEL OF THE STADIUM

No one unfamiliar with it can sense the atmosphere of a big prize fight – the early arrivals with their beer and peanuts to while away the weary wait in the bleachers; the milling, ever-growing crowds, cluttering up the long queues patiently shuffling towards the many entrances, the optimistic hangers-on, hoping for a free ticket from some influential acquaintance; the privileged few, very conscious of their briefs…The cries of the hot-dog vendors and piemen, the hooting of horns, the screech of brakes and clang of trams; and over all the glare of powerful arc lamps, illumining, through a haze of dust kicked up countless feet, a scene that only Hogarth could limn with justice…Inside, a sea of faces stretching tier upon tier to the furthest limits of the stadium until they touch the very roof; indescribable clamour of voices and laughter; sudden little eddies in that ocean of humanity marking where some point of honour is in dispute; an endless procession of champs, near champs, and challengers; two mighty roars as the gladiators clamber through the ropes…And then the deathly hush in the suddenly darkened amphitheatre: the brilliantly-lit ring, shining dazzlingly white in that vast circle of blackness, like a full moon seen through a rift in sombre clouds; two athletes, stripped to shorts and shoes, waiting for the fateful gong that will hurl them at each other like destroying angels. From the Cradle to the Grave, part 11.
Continue reading

The slow breaking Brogden story

Brogden1.jpg

"What was John Brogden thinking"? asked Miranda Devine, "Bob Carr’s resignation had just handed the NSW Opposition Leader the greatest gift of his career. But instead of capitalising on this stroke of luck, J-Bro let his hair down in rather exuberant style in front of a room full of journalists at a party at the new Hilton hotel."

Devine’s story appeared three weeks ago on 7 August. It seems that she had the story but didn’t spell it out. She did, however, let readers know that Brogden was treading close to the edge:

The Australian Hotels Association’s legendary annual knees-up is better attended by the fourth estate than just about any function on the Sydney media calendar.

The sushi and chocolate fondue fountain were temptations but the party and its aftermath downstairs in the Marble Bar were surely not the wisest place for an aspiring premier to let down his guard over a lemon-studded Corona or three.

Right now, discipline and focus are what 36-year-old Brogden needs if he is to have any hope of impressing NSW and achieving the big swing he needs in 2007.

After all, as his mentor John Howard is fond of saying about elections: "You can’t fatten a pig on market day."

Brogden was one piggy not destined to make it to market.

Meanwhile, on the ABC’s 7:30 Report site, there’s a reference to the shadowy figure "Alex Walker". Did they mean this bloke?

John Brogden: A heartfelt apology

One saying that I’ve never really understood is this one. “To err is human. To forgive is divine”.

What I don’t understand about it is that I imagine that the forgiveness spoken about is forgiveness that is called for – and that is most typically where one understands the genuine contrition of the other person. I don’t know about you people, but, at least within the compass of my comfortable middle class life, I’ve always found that forgiveness comes as a flood in such circumstances.

This was in my mind recently when I posted on Colin Allan McAlister’s apology for his racist remarks.

I’m naive about such things, and the quick read I gave to Andrew Landeryou that alerted me to the story suggests that maybe lots more was going on.

But I was moved by the apparent genuineness of Brogden’s resignation. Would that a few more of our pollies who’s reaction to such an expos© would be to do a bit more talking under wet cement might act with such decisiveness and honour.

A tip – and some armchair theorising about Google

The internet is where you go for armchair theorising about the internet and Google. Here’s a tip and some armchair theorising about Google.

Firstly I run two businesses – a discount mortgage broker and an economic policy consultancy. Neither couldn’t have existed in the form they do within the internet.

In fact when I set them up I did occasionally allow myself the ridiculous boast that I was “setting up an internet business” but only if I thought the person I was talking to was silly enough to believe me. I certainly didn’t believe it. I figured that for the businesses I was launching a mortgage broker and an economic policy consultancy that the ‘internet’ stuff was just an add on. A very handy bit of technology.

Then I got my first e-mail from Pakistan offering to redesign my site for peanuts. And I realised that there really was something new going on. Typical me I caught up with all the wave of hype after it had washed over me and crashed.
Continue reading

Public goods from public agencies

Lawrence Lessig says this.

the strong bias of public policy should be to spread public goods at their marginal cost. Compromises are no doubt necessary if private actors are to contribute voluntarily to the production of public goods; but public entities, such as govern-ments, should not indulge in these compromises unless they are necessary.

I agree and hope to put up a more substantial post on it in future. In the meantime, I’ve been provoked to this post by the contrast between the BBC and some other public agencies particularly in Australia. (Actually having visited the BBC website, its not clear how much better they’re doing than the ABC, but I take something that they’re doing as a jumping off point.)
Continue reading